At the heart of the stabilizationist ideal is a misunderstanding of the nature of money. Money is considered either a mere numeraire or a grandiose measure of values. Forgotten is the truth that money is desired and demanded as a useful commodity, even when this use is only as a medium of exchange. When a man holds money in his cash balance, he is deriving utility from it. Those who neglect this fact scoff at the gold standard as a primitive anachronism and fail to realize that “hoarding” performs a useful social function.... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 11). Now you know.
Wednesday, April 27, 2011
Central bank fallacy
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Unions: An economic evil
Consequently, at best, a union can achieve a higher, restrictionist wage rate for its members only at the expense of lowering the wage rates of all other workers in the economy. Production efforts in the economy are also distorted. But, in addition, the wider the scope of union activity and restrictionism in the economy, the more difficult it will be for workers to shift their locations and occupations to find nonunionized havens in which to work. And more and more the tendency will be for the displaced workers to remain permanently or quasi-permanently unemployed, eager to work but unable to find nonrestricted opportunities for employment. The greater the scope of unionism, the more a permanent mass of unemployment will tend to develop.... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 10). Now you know.
Monday, April 25, 2011
Socialism social-democratic style
[C]ontrary to the impression which socialism social-democratic style is intended to generate among the public, the difference between [socialism social-democratic style and traditional Marxist-style socialism] is not of a categorical nature. Rather, it is only a matter of degree.... says Hans-Hermann Hoppe in Theory of Socialism and Capitalism (page 62). Remember this, next time you argue with a "social-democrat" about the difference between the "welfare state" and the Soviet Union. The two are of the same category, differing only in a matter of degree of socialism.
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Money, what is it good for?
An increase in the supply of a producers’ good increases, ceteris paribus, the supply of a consumers’ good. An increase in the supply of a consumers’ good (when there has been no decrease in the supply of another good) is demonstrably a clear social benefit; for someone’s “real income” has increased and no one’s has decreased.Money, on the contrary, is solely useful for exchange purposes. Money, per se, cannot be consumed and cannot be used directly as a producers’ good in the productive process. Money per se is therefore unproductive; it is dead stock and produces nothing. Land or capital is always in the form of some specific good, some specific productive instrument. Money always remains in someone’s cash balance.
... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 11). Also, earlier in the same chapter:
At any one time there is a given total stock of the money commodity. This stock will, at any time, be owned by someone. It is therefore dangerously misleading to adopt the custom of American economists since Irving Fisher’s day of treating money as somehow “circulating,” or worse still, as divided into “circulating money” and “idle money.” This concept conjures up the image of the former as moving somewhere at all times, while the latter sits idly in “hoards.” This is a grave error. There is, actually, no such thing as “circulation,” and there is no mysterious arena where money “moves.” At any one time all the money is owned by someone, i.e., rests in someone’s cash balance. Whatever the stock of money, therefore, people’s actions must bring it into accord with the total demand for money to hold, i.e., the total demand for money that we have just discussed. For even pre-income money acquired in exchange must be held at least momentarily in one’s cash balance before being transferred to someone else’s balance.
There are many things in "modern" economics which are basically wrong or false or misleading. Rothbard cuts through the fat and brings us the meat.
Sunday, April 17, 2011
Patents: An unwanted State coercion
The most popular argument for patents among economists is the utilitarian one that a patent for a certain number of years is necessary to encourage a sufficient amount of research expenditure for inventions and innovations in processes and products. This is a curious argument, because the question immediately arises: By what standard do you judge that research expenditures are “too much,” “too little,” or just about enough? This is a problem faced by every governmental intervention in the market’s production. Resources—the better lands, laborers, capital goods, time—in society are limited, and they may be used for countless alternative ends. By what standard does someone assert that certain uses are “excessive,” that certain uses are “insufficient,” etc.?Also:
Many advocates of patents believe that the ordinary competitive conditions of the market do not sufficiently encourage the adoption of new processes and that therefore innovations must be coercively promoted by the government. But the market decides on the rate of introduction of new processes just as it decides on the rate of industrialization of a new geographic area. In fact, this argument for patents is very similar to the infant-industry argument for tariffs—that market processes are not sufficient to permit the introduction of worthwhile new processes. And the answer to both these arguments is the same: that people must balance the superior productivity of the new processes against the cost of installing them, i.e., against the advantage possessed by the old process in being already built and in existence. Coercively privileging innovation would needlessly scrap valuable plants already in existence and impose an excessive burden upon consumers. For consumers’ desires would not be satisfied in the most economic manner.Both quotes from Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 10: Monopoly and Competition). The entire chapter is very interesting, especially for those of us who are raised up to believe such ideas that the State can "prevent monopolies" and "protect consumers" from "cartels" and other such monsters. "Anti-trust" laws are anti-market laws. That about sums it up.
Sunday, April 03, 2011
Libertarianism and economics - a relation?
Directly, voluntary action—free exchange—leads to the mutual benefit of both parties to the exchange. Indirectly, as our investigations have shown, the network of these free exchanges in society—known as the “free market”—creates a delicate and even awe-inspiring mechanism of harmony, adjustment, and precision in allocating productive resources, deciding upon prices, and gently but swiftly guiding the economic system toward the greatest possible satisfaction of the desires of all the consumers. In short, not only does the free market directly benefit all parties and leave them free and uncoerced; it also creates a mighty and efficient instrument of social order. Proudhon, indeed, wrote better than he knew when he called “Liberty, the Mother, not the Daughter, of Order.”Ludwig von Mises was also on point when he said:
Economic knowledge necessarily leads to liberalism.Also, the following can be said:
Since liberalism is based on the recognition of the self-regulating capacity of civil society (i.e., the social order minus the state), any social theory that centers on that capacity furnishes powerful support to the liberal position.Libertarians are "obsessed" with freedom from coercion. By understanding economics, this "obsession" is strengthened (since freedom and economic prosperity are strongly linked). And that is why many libertarians are also very interested in economic policy, protest taxation, defend property rights, advocate freedom of choice, etc.
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Socialism, efficiency and the One Big Cartel
In the production sphere, socialism is equivalent to One Big Cartel, compulsorily organized and controlled by the State. Those who advocate socialist “central planning” as the more efficient method of production for consumer wants must answer the question: If this central planning is really more efficient, why has it not been established by profit-seeking individuals on the free market? The fact that One Big Cartel has never been formed voluntarily and that it needs the coercive might of the State to be formed demonstrates that it could not possibly be the most efficient method of satisfying consumer desires....says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 10). The socialist will never attempt to answer the question raised by Rothbard, because he can't. Actually, socialists don't highlight their "efficiency" argument so much anymore. Now they say: "Well, socialism isn't really that efficient, but we will impose it anyway in the name of "justice", so that everyone can suffer equally under the inefficiency of socialism."
Weakness and strength of the State
The weakness of the State lies in the fact that it is but an aggregate of humans; its strength derives from the general ignorance of this truism.... says here. This is something I should keep in mind more often. Sometimes I feel that it is a hopeless cause to fight the State. However, when I simply keep in mind that the State is just an aggregate of humans, and that the strength of the state lies in the the ignorance and submission of the general public, I regain my confidence and will to fight. The mission is clear: Educate the public. The goal: Free society.
Friday, March 25, 2011
Socialism, private cartels and economic calculation
The reason for the impossibility of calculation under socialism is that one agent owns or directs the use of all the resources in the economy. It should be clear that it does not make any difference whether that one agent is the State or one private individual or private cartel. Whichever occurs, there is no possibility of calculation anywhere in the production structure, since production processes would be only internal and without markets. There could be no calculation, and therefore complete economic irrationality and chaos would prevail, whether the single owner is the State or private persons.... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 9). Also:
The difference between the State and the private case is that our economic law debars people from ever establishing such a system in a free-market society. Far lesser evils prevent entrepreneurs from establishing even islands of incalculability, let alone infinitely compounding such errors by eliminating calculability altogether. But the State does not and cannot follow such guides of profit and loss; its officials are not held back by fear of losses from setting up all-embracing cartels for one or more vertically integrated products. The State is free to embark upon socialism without considering such matters. While there is therefore no possibility of a one-firm economy or even a one-firm vertically integrated product, there is much danger in an attempt at socialism by the State.So what does this mean? It means that a private "monopoly" is unlikely to ever come into existence (without aid from the State), and even thought it would, it would quickly run into economic chaos because it does not have a market to make reference to when calculating the cost of its operation. However, a State "monopoly" can simply drain the economy for blood until it has to default on its debt and obligations - a process that could take decades and will kill all life in its reach in the process.
Wednesday, March 23, 2011
Full employment on the free market
The “full employment” provided by the free market is employment to the extent that workers wish to be employed. If they refuse to be employed except at places, in occupations, or at wage rates they would like to receive, then they are likely to be choosing unemployment for substantial periods.... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 9). This is often forgotten. People talk about "unemployment" of men who want to work but simply cannot find any work! Rothbard explains why these men are out of work. Either they demand too much pay, or the government has made it too expensive for anyone to hire them (e.g. because of extensive benefits and taxes that follow each employee).
Friday, March 18, 2011
Productivity of labor
That each man receives his marginal value product means that each man is paid what he is worth in producing for consumers. But this does not mean that increases in his worth over the years are necessarily caused by his own improvement. On the contrary, as we have seen, the rise is primarily due to the increasing abundance of capital goods provided by the capitalists....says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 9). This is often forgotten. Why does a man, with no education and only minimal training, in general, earn a lot more in Europe than in Africa? Because in Europe, this man is given access to tools and equipment which the capitalist bought in order to improve the worth and value creation of his employee. Unions would do well to remember this. They tend to focus their efforts on consumption of existing capital, but forget that it is mainly increase in capital that really gives rise to an increase on the pay-check of the worker.
Sunday, March 13, 2011
Technology or capital?
It is logically obvious that while capital cannot engage in production beyond the limits of existing available knowledge, knowledge can and does exist without the capital necessary to put it to use. Technology and its improvement, therefore, play no direct role in the investment and production process; technology, while important, must always work through an investment of capital. As was stated above, even the most dramatic capital-saving invention, such as oil-drilling, can be put to use only by saving and investing capital....says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 8). And what does this mean? It means that in order to take advantage of new or improved technology, you need capital. Therefore, it is not possible to say that someone became rich because he has the latest and greatest technology. The latest and greatest technology could not have been obtained (purchased or developed) without capital.
Friday, February 18, 2011
Too little consumer spending?
A common fallacy, fostered directly by the net-income approach, holds that the important category of expenditures in the production system is consumers’ spending. Many writers have gone so far as to relate business prosperity directly to consumers’ spending, and depressions of business to declines in consumers’ spending. “Business cycle” considerations will be deferred to later chapters, but it is clear that there is little or no relationship between prosperity and consumers’ spending; indeed almost the reverse is true. For business prosperity, the important consideration is the price spreads between the various stages—i.e., the rate of interest return earned. It is this rate of interest that induces capitalists to save and invest present goods in productive factors. The rate of interest, as we have been demonstrating, is set by the configurations of the time preferences of individuals in the society. It is not the total quantity of money spent on consumption that is relevant to capitalists’ returns, but the margins, the spreads, between the product prices and the sum of factor prices at the various stages—spreads which tend to be proportionately equal throughout the economy....says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 6). Those (economists) who focus on "consumer spending" (or spending in general) as an indication of the health of the economy are missing the point.
Sunday, February 13, 2011
Function and income of the capitalist
Thus, capitalists advance present goods to owners of factors in return for future goods; then, later, they sell the goods which have matured to become present or less distantly future goods in exchange for present goods (money). They have advanced present goods to owners of factors and, in return, wait while these factors, which are future goods, are transformed into goods that are more nearly present than before. The capitalists’ function is thus a time function, and their income is precisely an income representing the agio of present as compared to future goods. This interest income, then, is not derived from the concrete, heterogeneous capital goods, but from the generalized investment of time. It comes from a willingness to sacrifice present goods for the purchase of future goods (the factor services). As a result of the purchases, the owners of factors obtain their money in the present for a product that matures only in the future.... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 6). This truth has been bent and manipulated by many. The socialist propaganda says that the capitalist is exploiting the worker, because the capitalist "only" pays his workers e.g. 95% of the sales revenue and pockets 5% himself. The fact, however, is that the capitalist is paying the worker from his own savings, so that the worker can carry out consumption immediately after work, while the capitalist has to wait until the product is sold at a later time. The "fee" for this waiting is the income of the capitalist.
Friday, February 11, 2011
Price determines costs
Factor payments are the result of sales to consumers and do not determine the latter in advance. Costs of production, then, are at the mercy of final price, and not the other way around.... says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 5). This important economic fact is mostly misunderstood by economists and the public in general. Most people think that prices are determined by costs of production (and I do admit, that this sounds logical). This is not true. Rothbard explains that in detail. So be aware!
Wednesday, February 09, 2011
Capitalists and income
If the owners of land and labor factors receive all the income (e.g., 100 ounces) when they own the product jointly, why do their owners consent to sell their services for a total of five ounces less than their “full worth”? Is this not some form of “exploitation” by the capitalists? The answer again is that the capitalists do not earn income from their possession of capital goods or because capital goods generate any sort of monetary income. The capitalists earn income in their capacity as purchasers of future goods in exchange for supplying present goods to owners of factors. It is this time element, the result of the various individuals’ time preferences, and not the alleged independent productivity of capital goods, from which the interest rate and interest income arise....says Rothbard, in Man, Economy and State (chapter 5). This is a very useful quote since it addresses the whole socialist-agenda of "capitalist exploitation" of workers. Are workers getting less than they deserve if they, combined, earn less than the price paid for the products they worked on and made? No. Why not? See above quotation.
Monday, January 17, 2011
That which is not 'for sale'
There are many possible examples of grading exchangeable and nonexchangeable goods on one’s value scale. Suppose that a man owns a piece of land containing an historic monument, which he prizes on aesthetic grounds. Suppose also that he has an offer for sale of the property for a certain sum of money, knowing that the purchaser intends to destroy the monument and use it for other purposes. To decide whether or not to sell the property, he must weigh the value to him of keeping the monument intact as against the value to him of the consumers’ goods that he could eventually buy with the money. Which will take precedence depends on the constitution of the individual’s value scale at that particular time. But it is evident that a greater abundance of consumers’ goods already at his disposal will tend to raise the value of the (unexchangeable) aesthetic good to him as compared with the given sum of money. Contrary, therefore, to the common accusation that the establishment of a money economy tends to lead men to slight the importance of nonexchangeable goods, the effect is precisely the reverse. A destitute person is far less likely to prefer the nonexchangeable to the exchangeable than one whose “standard of living” in terms of the latter is high...says Rothbard in Man, Economy and State (chapter 3). And how true! Who cared about things of beauty or historical significance when everyone was poor? It is only when the people become rich that they can afford to preserve, protect and preserve things of beauty and historical significance (as judged by someone). So do you want preserve the wildlife in Africa or the Buddha-statues in the Middle-East? Then preach capitalism for those regions!
Thursday, January 13, 2011
Market failure or lack of understanding?
Once one chases down the rabbit trails of "utility maximization" and the esoteric notions of "market failure," it is doubtful that one is going to understand simple opportunity cost.Exactly! More on this here: Krugman's Straw-Man Market System. Do you want to learn about economics? Then don't study economics in school.
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
Environmental scare tactics
It is important to recognize the behavioral pattern of governments, NGOs, and scientists by looking at similar scares, such as acid rain, Y2K, mad-cow disease, H1N1, and now climate change and terrorism. Fear and guilt are the usual tools used to rob citizens of their liberty and money. These scares foster the centralized masterminding of our choices and allow ever-greater transfers of power and wealth toward the government.
The Ozone Scare: A Retrospective - a valuable reminder of the tactics of the environmental movement (not to be confused with people actually concerned about the environment, without a socialist agenda).
Friday, August 27, 2010
The 'inevitability' of planning
The movement for planning owes its present strength largely to the fact that, while planning is in the main still an ambition, it unites almost all the single-minded idealists, all the men and women who have devoted their lives to a single task. The hopes they place in planning, however, are not the result of a comprehensive view of society, but rather of a very limited view, and often the result of a great exaggeration of the importance of the ends they place foremost...says Hayek, in Chapter 4 in his great classic, The Road to Serfdom. And how true!
Health experts want the State to "plan" cigarettes out of society of law-abiding citizens. Architects want cities demolished and rebuilt after their drawings (Icelandic example). Farmers demand State protection and subsidies to protect their current way of life and keep harsh competition away. Economists preach the need for powerful State central banks and data gathering institutions so they can play with interest rates (the price of money) and see how the real life reacts compared to sophisticated computer models.
The list is endless. Everywhere, "experts" and "specialists" in various studies talk about the need for some great State plan on their favorite subject, with themselves in control (of course). The inevitable result: A central command economy of some sort. Is that what we want?
